I just watched the telly premiere of Return of the King (ROTK).
First off, I’m a colossal Lord of the Rings fan. I absolutely adored the books. A friend puts it succinctly, “Tolkien spends two pages describing grass”…but it is precisely his devoted attention to detail that undergirds the brushstrokes with which readers paint, the arcs of vividness which weave together to bring life to the canvas of imagination.
When you witness a book you’ve loved as a child being weaved into reality (albeit on the screen) right before your eyes… it’s indescribable joy, muted only in the cognisance that it isn’t, after all, real.
Although the films have their blemishes and take more liberties with the plot than I'd have liked, the transgression of book to film was, for most part, handsomely crafted. I recall the very first moments of watching Fellowship of the Ring, when Gandalf rode into the hobbits' dwelling and Frodo was lying on a tree reading a book... my initial reaction was, "THIS IS THE SHIRE!!!!" The luxuriant grass, the smials, the overarching trees, the languorous waft of smoke emanating from Frodo’s pipe… everything just clicked into place. As I beheld the Shire, I felt as if the book had leapt to life.
And since I had just watched ROTK, I’ll do a stock-take:
Scenes That Screamed “Two Thumbs Up!!”
Frodo and Sam – I don’t think I can ever look at Elijah Wood and Sean Astin without images of curly hair, hair feet, lembas bread and elven cloaks cropping up in my head. I mean, they ARE Frodo and Sam. I could nitpick all day about the movie not giving enough screen-time and credence to the heartrending friendship between these two, but overall I am chuffed with the characterisation.
C'mon Mr Frodo! I can't carry it for you, but I can carry you!

Sean Astin was lacklustre for the first two installments, but in ROTK he truly crawled into Sam’s skin. Many folks quibbled that Elijah Wood was too young to play Frodo (indeed, he was then 17 and Frodo was, shock shock horror horror, a 50-year-old), but his visage was perfect for a hobbit – pinchable cheeks, porcelain complexion, childlike countenance and all. And thanks to his large, liquid, beseeching doe eyes which made him look like a hypnotised wombat, he bore an ethereal quality that reminds me of Faramir’s quote that Frodo had an “elvish air” about him.
Minas Tirith – The lush, sweeping shots of the white city of Gondor were simply awesome. It was amazing how faithful they were to Alan Lee’s illustrations. And the scenes depicting the lighting of beacons were stunning cinematography.
Minas Tirith in the background.

Pippin sings – This scene was pure genious. Billy Boyd has a great voice and the lament was hauntingly wistful. After Denethor sent Faramir on his suicide charge, he proceeded, in good cheer, to have lunch – and looked disconcertingly like a participant in those "Eat 100 Hotdogs in 3 Minutes" competition, breaking the bones of the meat and having red tomato juice splattering on his lips – an imagery of death and blood, and a poignant reminder that this is indeed a cup of bitterness that he has mixed for himself.
Theoden leading the Rohirrim to battle at the Pelennor fields – Loved it when Theoden rode his horse and clanged his sword against the outstretched spears of his troops. And the build-up of the Rohirrim chanting "Death! Death! Death!" in a ominous timbre was so thuddingly resounding that I felt as though my eardrums were about to rupture (or was it just the sound system?). “Fell deeds awake! Now for wrath, now for ruin, and the red dawn! Forth Eorlingas!!!!!”
The Battle of the Pelennor Fields – The mammoth Oliphaunts trampling everyone in sight, the boulders catapulted from Minas Tirith, the macabre charge of Grond (i.e. Middle Earth’s equivalent of suckling pig) which sounded like a death knell on Gondor’s fortifications and the chivalrous, hopeless charge of the Rohirrim. Words can do no justice.
The Oliphaunts making human chowder of everything in their path.

Scenes That Inspired Psychotic Throwing Of Popcorn And Frothing At The Mouth
The Pyre of Denethor – What a scrappy, incoherent scene. Denethor came across as a surly, cantankerous one-sided curmudgeon, bereft of any vestige of pride and nobility. And Gandalf budgeoning Denethor on the head – what on earth is this????
Minas Morgul – A real disappointment which looked like some ice carving at a tacky wedding, with sleazy green lights emanating from it.
Aragron's Sissy Hair – Those who watched the first two installments would remember that Aragron was a greasy, bedraggled Ranger that looked like he needed sand-blasting - scruffy in that uber cool kinda way. In ROTK, however, he turned up looking all preened and - gasp! - clean. Worse still, his hair, once so gloriously stained with grime, was tied up in an effeminate schoolgirl do.
Aragorn looking neat - what's next - ribbons in his hair?!?

Peter Jackson’s Ninja Turtle Moments – The battle scenes were unfortunately marred by Jackson’s seeming chronic inability to refrain from gratuitous moments of cheesiness. Proof: That cliched smirk on chief orc Gothmog's face (as an aside, Gothmog looked totally like a cross between Miss Piggy and Quasimodo) after he dodged a boulder hurled by the Gondorians. Proof: Legolas' personal moment of bravura as he despatched the Oliphaunt... how many sickening vanity shots do we have to stomach of him just cos he's the goodlooking one? Must we really be subject to such an infantile, Streetfighter-ish farce of triumph?
Eowyn and Merry kill the Witchking – This one made me so angry that I want to bite off my tongue. It was so damn fast that I nearly missed Merry stabbing the Witchking. And woe is me, they divided the scene into two!! The sequence was absolutely butchered with the screen cutting to show Aragorn and co arriving in the Cosair ships. Plus, Eowyn removing her helm to reveal that she is female was totally unrealistic... stab the Darth Vader lookalike already, gal.
Frodo's lousy elvish – I laughed when he shouted "Aiya Eärendil elenion ancalima!" in Shelob's Lair. Nice take, but it just sounded... vulgar.
Frodo in Shelob's Lair.

The Eye of Sauron – Is it just me or did the Eye look terribly tacky in ROTK? It was roving this way and that, as though some washed-out, punk DJ from the 80s was trying to beam some cheap red disco light across Mordor… unforgivable.
Mount Doom – Love the way Frodo and Sam mirrored Isildur and Elrond in the Second Age but the CGI was a disappointment here, cos the lava was so articfically bright and jarring that the effect looked more like an angry child’s drawing with a fluorescent marker than the gazillions-of-dollars CGI you’d expect. Though Gollum’s demise was suitably sinister – he sunk into the lava painlessly, as though pain could no longer hurt him cos he was so obsessed with the Ring.
No explanation on why Frodo departed for the Grey Havens – There're a lot of interesting theories which posit the reason for Frodo leaving Middle-Earth. One thing that initially bugged me in the books is that Frodo never enjoyed the fruits of his labour. But in leaving everything for Sam, and making Sam the one who eventually savoured the completeness of what life on “this good earth” has to offer – this just enhanced the bittersweet ending for me. For is that not what epitomises sacrifice? "I tried to save the Shire, and it has been saved, but not for me. It must often be so Sam, when things are in danger, someone has to give them up, lose them, so that others may keep them." Whatever the interpretation, it is the most important sense of closure, and it was criminal to leave it completely unexplained.
But ultimately, after I watched ROTK, a part of me will be concluded and put to closure. The three movies (and the three years) have been one hell of a ride, and I'm grateful for this experience. In the eternal words of Bilbo: "I regret to announce that - this is the end." Yet, it isn’t quite over – the memory lies quiescent in the mind, waiting to be stoked, and then I must yield to the hearkening to read the books once every few years. That, I suppose, is the haunting beauty of coming across a darn good story – it never quite stays out of mind. =)
Tags: Lord Of The Rings, Return Of The King, Frodo Baggins, Aragorn, Tolkien, Peter Jackson, Elijah Wood, Sean Astin, Viggo Mortensen, Orlando Bloom, Ian McKellen